Home
Subscribe to Psychic News
About Psychic News
Spiritual videos
Issues of Psychic News
List of churches, centres and businesses who sell Psychic News magazine
List of churches, centres and businesses who sell Psychic News magazine
Advertise with Psychic News magazine
Advertise on this website
Contact us
 
Search this Site

PLACEBO EFFECT CANNOT EXPLAIN HEALING RESULTS

     

The placebo effect complicates assessments of new treatments
 

A LARGE proportion of the scientific and medical community dismiss healing and healers on the basis that patients’ unexpected improvements and even cures are simply the result of the well-known “placebo” effect.

This phenomenon, in which a sick patient believes he or she is receiving effective medicine, treatment or surgery and responds accordingly, is real and common, and improvements do occur even though the medication is inert, the surgery is a sham or the patient is being lied to about the nature of the treatment.

The placebo effect complicates assessments of new treatments because it has to be taken into account in assessing pharmaceutical test results.

It hinges on patient expectation and for that reason it is easy – and perhaps understandable – that it is used by those who are sceptical of healing powers to explain away the positive results that are often achieved by healers and others who offer complementary and alternative approaches to medicine.

The sceptics could be right – to a degree. Many who consult healers will certainly have an expectation that the treatment they receive will bring about improvement. But could it be that, in addition to any self-induced placebo element that benefits them, something equally important is making a difference to their health?

The answer to that, say UK researchers who have reviewed the evidence, is a resounding “Yes”. But who or what is that mysterious “something else”?

If a patient visits a healer and then improves dramatically, can we be certain that it is the healer who should get the credit (assuming, for the moment, that any placebo effect makes a minimal contribution)?  Could it be that the patient’s family or friends had also prayed for him or her, or sent their own distant healing thoughts, and that it was these actions which brought about the improvement, rather than the healer?

Such complexities make it difficult to say with certainty that a healer can take all the credit, and similar objections are raised in discussions about the efficacy of healing generally.

 
The overall results of this meta-analysis suggest that non-contact healing results in relatively small, but highly statistically significant effects on non-human targets as well as on humans. Indeed, both the effect size and statistical assurance were slightly greater in some of the non-human systems than they were for humans – Professor Chris Roe
 

 
But Professor Chris Roe, Director of the Centre for the Study of Anomalous Psychological Processes at the University of Northampton, and fellow researchers Charmaine Sonnex and Elizabeth Roxburgh, have risen to the challenge by focusing a new study on analyses of particular types of healing experiments.

They looked at research in which the healing interventions involved no contact with the human recipients, isolating 57 studies that satisfied their strict criteria.

They also did a similar state-of-the-art meta-analysis of 49 studies in which, rather than humans, the beneficiaries of non-contact or distant healing were biological systems, such as plants or cell and tissue cultures, that “presumably do not have expectancies about the effects of treatment or have communities of peers sending them positive intentions for their well-being”.

Their findings, revealed in “Two Meta-Analyses of Non-contact Healing Studies” published in Explore (Vol 11, No 1, Jan/Feb 2015), show that healing intent or energy channelling does produce positive results, including accelerating the germination of seeds and the enzymatic activity within cell cultures.

Commenting on the findings, Sue Knight, chief executive of the Confederation of Healing Organisations (CHO), which provided funding support for the research, said:

“The human trials showed that healing generated statistically significant positive outcomes. Humans aside: cells in a petri dish, animals and plants all showed a positive response to healing and indeed a highly statistically significant effect was seen. It’s impossible for cells, plants and animals to experience any kind of placebo effect, therefore this proved without doubt that healing can make a difference.”

Knight, a healing practitioner for 20 years, adds: “While results of the research are groundbreaking for healing, there is still much we do not know or understand. Metaphysical reactions do not carry the same easily understood reactions as conventional medicine.

“But what we do know now, in a scientifically demonstrable sense, is that healing intent is what made the difference. This healing intent was used with all the research subjects forming part of the research. This is not new to holistic practitioners, but allows us to understand and impart on a greater level what contributes to positive results that can occur.”

Sue Knight, chief executive of The Confederation of Healing Organisations    
Sue Knight, chief executive of
The Confederation of Healing Organisations

A discussion paper on these findings, written by Paul Dieppe, Professor of Health and Wellbeing at the University of Exeter Medical School, Devon, and Professor Chris Roe, the lead researcher of the meta-analyses, was published in the British Holistic Medical Association’s Journal of Holistic Healthcare (Issue 12.1, Spring 2015).

Under the title “Is Healing an Option to Aid Sustainable Healthcare Futures?” they observe: “The overall results of this meta-analysis suggest that non-contact healing results in relatively small, but highly statistically significant effects on non-human targets as well as on humans. Indeed, both the effect size and statistical assurance were slightly greater in some of the non-human systems than they were for humans.”

And they conclude that “the data clearly indicate that non-contact healing intention can result in beneficial outcomes on both human and non-human targets”.

The same authors also contributed a very positive Editorial in the International Journal of Nursing Studies 52 (2015), making the point that healing intent is not confined to healers:

“It seems likely that the positive intention of one person to help another person (or another living organism) to improve is the key to success, as this is an aspect of healing that is stressed by many healers, including nurses who practise therapeutic touch.”

It is to be hoped that the Northampton study will encourage even greater scientific scrutiny of healing energy and a broader acceptance that healing intent could be an even more powerful well-being mechanism than the placebo effect. 


A meticulously researched two-volume biography, with 90+ archival photographs, of Canada’s longest serving prime minister and most persistent Spiritualist and psychic investigator.  WILLIAM LYON MACKENZIE KING  King’s spiritual path led to the London Spiritualist Alliance. His UK contacts included Oliver Lodge, the Duchess of Hamilton, and mediums Hester Dowden, Helen Hughes, and Geraldine Cummins. With world leaders and British royalty, King did not shy in private from sharing his faith in survival. As a Canadian statesman, he tried to appease Hitler. With Churchill and President Roosevelt, King became complicit in the birth of the atom bomb.  Published by White Crow Books For details: survivalresearch.ca/TSPM Kindle edition available from Amazon    
 1st Edition  OUT  NOW!! Clear and Profound Explanations. Simple and Easy to Read. www.ethericweb.com    A-Z INDEX OF SPIRITUALISM A GUIDE TO PSYCHIC AND SPIRITUAL DEVELOPMENT This Book contains important Spiritual Teachings that are all relevant for todays Modern Spiritualism. It is filled with wonderful truths and precious Spiritual knowledge. From Awakening to Spiritual Awareness, Psychic Abilities to Spiritual Mediumship, from Channelling to Trance .. Spiritual Guides to Planes of Existence, Clairvoyance to Visions, Meditation to Stillness, Cosmic Energy to Ethereal Being. The Book Will Guide You Through All The Many Aspects Needed For Your Spiritual Journey.   OVER 300 PAGES AND 32 ILLUSTRATIONS   Buy Now!! £22.00 + Postage and Package    
PSYCHIC • MEDIUM • TAROT Reliable • Informative • No-nonsense Psychic phone & written readings Elizabeth Francis www.elizabethfrancis.co.uk    
Can you make this into a website banner advert please.  The photo is attached but there is a better version on her website.The text is:  Barbara Psychic Medium and Author.  I give worldwide phone and email readings. I always give a timeline, and I record the reading for you.  On my website you will find free e-books to develop your psychic abilities.  I also offer a mediumship course with personal guidance.  First-time callers receive 5 minutes free when purchasing a half-hour reading.  My website is www.barbarathemedium.com  Follow me on Instagram: @bbpsychicmedium  Looking forward to connect with you!    
Speak to one of our many Live Readers now Mediums, Tarot, Psychics Seeking Guidance, Love, Happiness or Connecting to Spirit £1.50 per minute plus your network charge  www.psychicspotlightreadings.org Readings are for entertainment purposes only     Callers must be age 18+  Callers must have bill payers’ permission.  All calls are recorded      
PAST LIVES REVISITED  REMEMBERING WHO WE REALLY ARE Healing Karmic Trauma and Karmic Grief by Aurora Borealisz FACE YOUR FEAR LOVE YOUR LIFE  A mind-opening journey on the spiritual evolution of the Soul on earth and how this can negatively affect our lives, and how we can heal them. BUY NOW  amazon.com/dp/1916873464   MERCEDES GARCIA  Spiritualist Medium  for over 35 years  Phone, Skype or ZOOM  Readings available  Contact me for  further details   Tel: 07403 780 569 mercedes.garcia.medium@gmail.com        
PSYCHIC WENDY DOVE A Hand For You To Hold In Life    SPECIAL OFFER  A 30-minute reading for £30 - just quote 'Soul30' when booking    CREDIT/DEBIT CARD:  UK 0207 111 6126 EIRE 1800 719 347   UK TEXT DOVE  to 60016  (Just £1.00 per/text from UK)   PAY ON PHONE BILL:  UK 0906 7393 020 (0906 £1.00 p/min)  EIRE 1580 600 306 (PRS Charged at 2.50 per/min)  EIRE TEXT DOVE to 57777 (Just 2 per/text from Eire)   www.wendydove.co.uk   Wendy is available for pre-bookings Mon-Thurs 1.3 pm and 7-9pm. Please also check her website to see if she is available at all other times. However please call 02476 441063 to arange readings outside of these hours. Wendy's pin: 6400  We can take payments via PayPal at £1.00 per/min when you book a Reading with Wendy  GOOGLE REVIEWS 5* See Wendy's testimonials on the website  SMS cost £1/msg. max £2/reply +*your standard network charge 18+ STOP? 'Text, Stop' to 60016  SP: DSMS help? 02071116126. Eire SP: MTL. Helpline: 0766801002. 2EUR/msg +your standard network charge, 18+ To stop txt STOP to 5777 SP: DSMS help? 1800 719 347. Eire 1580 calls cost 2.50 per/minute. Must have bill payer's permision. Service for Entertainment only.     
Elstree Psychic Foundation  Tarot Course for Beginners  Starting Tuesday 12 September  10 week course (7.30 – 9.30pm)  Tutored by renowned  Psychic MediumsTarot Tutors J. Barnes & L. Vine  FREE introduction on Tuesday 5 September at 7.30pm  Limited spaces, call to reserve on 07931 846089  Venue Allum Hall, 2 Allum Lane, Elstree, Borehamwood, Hertfordshire  WD6 3PJ  For further information or details of our other courses, visit our website at www.elstreepsychicfoundation.co.uk       The Most Affordable Psychic Readings  Discover Your Own Personal Future Get Answers to All Your Questions Trusted Psychics  Over 400 World Class Psychic Readers Available Mediums, Clairvoyants, Astrologers & Tarot Readers Connect with Psychic Experts with Natural Abilities  Choose Your Psychic Today 	 Call Today 09040070663 (Call cost 45p per minute + network access charges apply)  www.trusted-psychics.co.uk  
Leaving Faith, Finding Meaning   A Preacher's Daughter's Search for God   The strange disappearance of a set of keys radically transformed Lynne Renoir’s life from suffering and disappointment to one filled with love and profound insight.   In her new book, Lynne reveals how the spirit world mysteriously intervened, connecting her with the extraordinary wisdom she now offers readers.   AVAILABLE AT AMAZON   Download a FREE EXCERPT at www.lynnerenoir.com  
My Soul Enslaved   Words and pictures from the abolitionists and enslaved peoples of the past through the medium of Psychic/Spiritual Art By Sheila Moore  Available through Amazon and bookshops or my website www.psychicartspiritualvisions.com  
Psychics Connections 03 MINUTES FREE    Speak with a live psychic now Find your way to love & happiness 3 minutes free for all new members From the US: 619-374-8181 From the UK: (001) 619-374-8181 www.psychicsconnections.com    
Ethel Post Parrish: Mediumship in America  by Gerald O'Hara    The first biography of Ethel Post Parrish, America’s most versatile materialisation medium and succesful business woman.   Using never before published sources, the author breaks new ground in research and looks at Ethel’s life in the context of the Spiritualist movement of the 1930s/1950s.   240 pages, 24 illustrations.   Available from Amazon in paperback and ebook for £12.01 and USA $15.00  Also available at ebay
     
How to view every issue of Psychic News ever published, from 1932 to the present day! Issues of it in newspaper format, from 1932 to 2010, are being made available online for FREE as a historic archive by the University of Manitoba at: https://libguides.lib.umanitoba.ca/psychicnews and every issue in its magazine format, from 2011 to the present day, can be viewed by online subscribers at www.psychicnews.org.uk for just £26 for 1 year or £14 for 6 months
  
The Spiritualist Society of Athens "The Divine Light" – en.divinelight.org.gr

The Psychic News logos are UK and Community registered trade marks of
Psychic Press Limited (Company Number 7806155)